'A devo fa’ vergognà
Scene in a bus, 2017
Repetition | Emphasized reiteration of a word, phrase, or even syllable. Repetition involves a slowing down, a stopping, or a stand-still of speech, but it also arouses the listener’s interest and produces numerous poetic and rhetorical effects.
There are different ways of using repetition as a tool in speech, depending on which utterances are available to a speaker in a given situation and the ways they can find to vary them. There are two main forms of repetition: suspension, which takes place when an element temporarily loops itself within a larger utterance, and refrains, where the utterance’s entire structure is looped.
Let us begin with an announcement made on Radio London during World War II. Here, the message is reduced to a repeated phrase: it is precisely the act of repeating the utterance (stressed by “twice we say”) that lets us know it is a coded message.
On a radio show, one can hear researcher Bruno Karsenti’s diction stumble on certain utterances, producing the stuttering repetition of a residual “uh.” This bouncing around creates light pauses in the flow of his speech. Another temporality takes shape, changing the listener’s focus.
Indeed, the repetition of a word, syllable, or phrase can lead to a different form of understanding that becomes increasingly complex over the course of each repetition: thus, as Charles Bukowski repeats the utterance “green trees,” it progressively loses its color: “OK, what you gonna do with it?”
Whether used as a poetic device or an insistent example, repetition also functions as an argument for maintaining a speaker’s authority in a given situation. This can be heard in a repetition made by Igor Stravinsky, or in this interview that feels something like an interrogation.
Contrary to the special case of the Radio London announcement cited above, a repetition’s existence is often linked to the variations a speaker imprints upon it. Whether with Senator Robert Byrd condemning dog fighting or filmmaker Jean-Marie Straub in discussion after a projection, emotion—real or faked—is concentrated into a limited group of words that speakers give resonance to by varying tone, intensity, and address. Spacing and overemphasis are combined when Nicolaz Ceauşescu’s speech, interrupted by a surging crowd, is reduced to an “Alo!” (“Calm down!”), first repeated as an order then as a plea to his angry people. In a hypnosis recording for insomniacs, the repetition of an utterance also implies the repetition of a form of silence with various characteristics.
Speech is often suspended because it is indexed to an external activity. But although repetition gives this auction its momentum back, suspension is more often a means of continuing or accentuating the course of things, as it does in this birth or in this majorette training session, or as shown by this pornographic actress. Repetition varies according to the demands of the activity it is indexed to.
This part of the collection contains cases that lie somewhere between suspension and refrains: through lexical exhaustion, repetition no longer functions as a temporary pause in the flux of speech, but makes up the very structure of its discourse. It is no longer a deviation but a situation builder within a given discourse’s routine.
Learning situations function this way by repeating an utterance’s successive elements, as with the teacher himself in this dictation, or the teacher and student in this method for learning Russian. In these speech situations, vocabulary is limited to a finite whole. It can take the form of information directed at users; it can be the name of the protagonists in a love story; or it can be instructions given during gym class, where utterances are combined randomly, just like the calls of this Turkish grinder.
In this example, the repetition of single utterances is combined with a number of variations and modifications, as in this excerpt from the film The Pink Panther.
Whether in this recording of tongue twisters or this score by Georges Aperghis, the pattern that emerges from repetition highlights the formal properties of speech. An ordinary poetic gesture can lead to exhausting a phrase and its meaning, as in this Joseph Beuys performance, to accepting one’s sexual orientation, as in this scene from André Téchiné’s Wild Reeds, to accompanying a parturient woman’s work, or even to underscoring a political message, as in this speech by an activist during a radio show about the Gruss circus.
Repetition is also a particularly effective tool for group-building: the repetition of a slogan allows a choir of prisoners to take shape in this scene from Jim Jarmusch’s Down by Law. Other types of chorality built through repetition can be heard in this praise to Allah, or in this protest-like artistic performance.
As we saw in Nicolaz Ceauşescu’s address and in the Pink Panther excerpt, repeating an utterance allows one to clarify, or even modify, its meaning over the course of its repetition. Thus, in this clip from The Wire and in this recording of a woman speaking to a donkey, only the words “fuck” and “sta” stand for the description of a murder and the driving of an animal, respectively.
This collection also provides several excerpts of repetitions that modify or corrupt the repeated utterance that structures them. In this excerpt of an improvised Joaõ Fiadeiro performance, the initial utterance is augmented by temporary additions, though this augmentation can also take place through accumulation, as it does in this Christophe Fiat reading, or add itself to a series, as it does with this man reading a newspaper’s obituary notices. In this example, the poet Jaap Blonk repeats an utterance, increasingly compressing it until it is crushed into a succession of purely percussive consonants.
Scene in a bus, 2017
Scène from the funfair 'Foire du Trône', recording by Daniel Deshays, date unknown.
Phone conversation between a manager and an employee, excerpt from the TV show, Cash Investigation, France Télévisions, 2017.
Pastor preaching in the street, São Paulo, 2012.
Victoria Azarenka and Caroline Wozniacki, excerpt of a tennis semi-final, 2010.
Recording scene for a radio advertisement, 2018.
Excerpt of Nicolaz Ceauşescu’s final speech, Televiziunea Românã, 1989.
Lynn Margulis, extrait d’un entretien, NHK-TV, années 80.
Michelle Bachmann, excerpt from a TV debate hosted by Anderson Cooper for the Republican primary, 2011.
Marie-Thérèse Allier, Sabine Macher, recording by Sabine Macher, 2012.
Scene from a family, excerpt of a YouTube video, 2014.
Arrival of a skating race at the Strasbourg Europe Races, YouTube video, 2008.
Brice Robin, excerpt of a press conference broadcast by I-Télé, 2015.
Hervé Listeur, excerpt from a magic show, 2011.
Director's instructions on the shooting of a porn movie, 2000s.
Senator Robert Byrd, excerpt of a speech to the United States Senate, 2007.
Radio test, excerpt of a recording for the film Tongue Twisters by Érik Bullot, 2007.
Scene from a hike, excerpt of a video posted on YouTube, 2015.
Excerpt from an interview with an apprentice in luxury clock-making, 2019.
Parrot training session, video posted on YouTube, 2007.
Joan Porras, message of support for political prisoners, 2018.
Geoffrey Carey, Frédéric Danos, excerpt of the recording of predictions, 2019.
Conversation between a woman and her dog, personal recording, 2017
Scene from an unloading of merchandise, personal recording by Claude Vittiglio, 2003.
Excerpt of a report by Vincent Lapierre, Le média pour tous, 2019.
Marc-Olivier Fogiel, Hamé, Ekoué, Danièle Evenou, excerpt of the show On ne peut pas plaire à tout le monde, France 3, 2005.
Workers and Bruno Le Maire, excerpt of a video posted on Youtube, 2019.
Excerpt from a game of Counter strike global offensive, personal recording, 2018.
Pacific sound 3003, YouTube video, 2014.
Market scene, 2019
Noëlle Obscarskas, YouTube video, 2012.
Man reading an obituary, recording by Gauthier Tassart, 2007.
Excerpt of the television game show Des chiffres et des lettres, Antenne 2, 1972.
Pierre Velay, excerpt of the recording Accouchement sans douleur, 1960s.
Scene at the dentist's, excerpt from a YouTube video, 2010s.
Jacqueline, Six fois deux / Sur et sous la communication (episode 6b) from Jean-Luc Godard and Anne-Marie Miéville, 1976.
Tax Center Waiting Message, 2019.
Bailiff's report, from the show Les pieds sur terre, France Culture, 2015.
Monsieur Fraize, excerpt of the comedy sketch “Coiffeur de stars à Cannes,” On n'demande qu'à en rire, France 2, 2011.
Excerpt of a hypnosis recording, unknown date.
Opéra Bastille usher, recording by Olivier Normand, 2013
Jaap Blonk, excerpt of the recording Flux de Bouche, 1993.
Woman at her window, video posted on Youtube, 2013.
Commentator of the running of the bulls in Camargue, personal recording, 2019.
Excerpt of a YouTube video, 2013.
Extract from a videoconference, 2020.
Father Boulad, excerpt of a sermon, 2014.
Zoé Konstantopoulou and Stelios Virvidakis, vote session at the Greek parliament, 2013.
Elissa Knight, Ben Burtt, excerpt from the film WALL-E by Andrew Stanton, 2008.
Georges Bégué, excerpt of the show Les Français parlent aux Français, Radio Londres, 1940-1944.
Jean-Pierre Léaud, excerpt of the film Baisers volés by François Truffaut, 1968.
Excerpt from a boxing training for children, YouTube, 2013.
Voicemail message, 2019
Majorette rehearsal, unknown source, 2000s.
Igor Stravinsky, excerpt of a rehearsal of Vorona.
Auction at Christie's, excerpt of a YouTube video, 2008.
Excerpt of the video Young Girls Share Cock, posted on YouPorn, 2010.
Dominic West and Wendell Pierce, excerpt of the show The Wire by David Simon and Ed Burns, 2002.
Announcement in the Paris Metro, line 14, 2010.
Conversation with a piglet, YouTube video, 2009.
André Tubeuf, excerpt from the radio show André Tubeuf Mémoire, France Musique, 2021.
Kenneth E. Hagin, excerpt from a preach, 2003
Charles Bukowski, excerpt of an interview, unknown date.
Scene from a panicked airplane, YouTube video, 2009.
Excerpt of the recording Les Techniques de sommeil, unknown date.
Paula White, excerpt from a preaching in support of the recount during the U.S. presidential election, 2020.
Kristina Rose and Manuel Ferrara, excerpt of the film Kristina Rose Is Slutwoman, 2011.
Eve Ensler, excerpt of the TED Talk “Embrace Your Inner Girl,” 2009.
Roberto Benigni, Tom Waits, John Lurie, excerpt of the film Down by Law by Jim Jarmusch, 1986.
Steve Martin et Charlotte Maier, excerpt of the film The Pink Panther by Shawn Levy, 2006.
Man protesting as he is threatened by police, YouTube, 2014.
Lawrence Wiener, excerpt of the sound art piece Having Rolled Before Incarceration..., 1973.
Jérôme, excerpt from the show Radio Tisto, l’émission des jeunes de l’hôpital de jour d’Antony, Radio Libertaire, 2020.
Party conversation, recording by Olivier Nourisson, 2000s.
Joseph Beuys, excerpt of the performance Ja Ja Ja Ja Ja Nee Nee Nee Nee Nee, Staatliche Kunstakademie Düsseldorf, 1968.
Video session of Emotional Freedom Technique, YouTube, 2013
Patrice Chéreau, excerpt of an interview during the news, Antenne 2, 1983.
Scene from a demonstration in Algiers posted on YouTube, 2019.
Excerpt of the show Questions pour un champion, unknown date.
Gaël Morel, excerpt of the film Les Roseaux sauvages by André Téchiné, 1994.
Calibre Auto Recording, 60s.
Scene from dinner, personal recording by Valérie Louys, 2013.
Jean-Claude Bajeux, speech at Yves Volel's funeral, 1987.
Bernard Pivot, excerpt of La Dictée d'Amiens, 2005.
Stéphane Bern, Alexis Grüss, an activist, excerpt of the show Le Fou du roi, France Inter, 2008.
Prayer in Kenya, excerpt of Les Voix du monde : une anthologie des expressions vocales, year unknown.
Mister mv at Z event 2021, Twitch TV, 2021.
Josep Maria Puyal, excerpt from a soccer commentary, Catalunya Ràdio, 2007.
Drawing of the Sorteo de Navidad, Christmas lottery, 2014.
Excerpt of the ASSIMIL method for learning Russian, unknown date.
Moi Renee, excerpt of the performance Miss Honey, 1992.
François Hollande, excerpt of the presidential debate held between the two rounds of France’s presidential elections, France 2, 2012.
Dominique de Villepin, excerpt of a speech at the French National Assembly, 2006.
Excerpt of a bull auction, 2011.
The Monty Python, excerpt of The Monty Python's Flying Circus, 1972.
Slogans in a protest, 2018.
Excerpt from a stream of Dead Cells par At0miumVOD, vidéo Youtube, 2018.
Breathing exercise in a singing class, personal recording, 2012.
Excerpt of a sports show on France Bleu La Rochelle, 2013.
Call of a rag-picker, Serbia, 2007.
Jean-Marie Straub, excerpt of a debate held in a movie theater, 2000s.
Excerpt of a self-development seminar, Germany, 2014.
Excerpt of the recording Les Techniques de sommeil, unknown date.
Edwy Plenel, Robert Ménard, excerpt of the show Mots croisés, France 2, 2011.
Scolding, video posted on YouTube, 2016.
Excerpt from an ASMR video, YouTube, 2019.
Excerpt of La Belle Istanbul by Jeanne Robet, Arte Radio, 2006.
Martine Viard, Récitation 10 (partie gauche : 1ère version) by Georges Aperghis, 1978.
Excerpt of the film Avec le sang des autres by Bruno Muel (Groupe Medvedkine), 1974.
Message posted on YouTube, 2019.
Street scene, excerpt from a video posted on YouTube, 2014
Soliloquy on a subway platform, personal recording, 2016.
Steffen Königer, speech to the German parliament, 2016.
Litany of a beggar, personal recording, 2019.
Christophe Fiat, excerpt of a reading of Une aventure de Catwoman, 2001.
Woman speaking to a donkey, recording by Tiago Pereira, Portugal, 2000s.
Scene from a classroom in Bulgaria, 2013.
Bruno Karsenti, excerpt of the show La Suite dans les idées, France Culture, 2006.
Street scene, personal recording, 2021.
Andrei Lado, excerpt from an articulatory gymnastics class, YouTube, 2012.
Barack Obama, beginning of his speech accepting the democratic nomination, 2008.
Excerpt of a demonstration of the “Tadoma speechreading” method for the hearing and visually impaired, Sensory Communication Group at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2011.
Daniel Linehan, excerpt of the performance Not about Everything, 2007.
Chant during a protest in Athens, personal recording, 2012.
Gouy Gui, excerpt of a YouTube video, 2012.
Account recorded by the photographer Antoine Bruy, 2016.
Scene from the subway, personal recording, 2016.
Pierre Velay, excerpt of the recording Accouchement sans douleur, 1960s.
Protest, excerpt of the website Révoltes FM by Bruno Guiganti.
Child learning to read, personal recording, Sweden, 2017.
Excerpt of the show Choses vues, ORTF, 1969.
Cláudia Dias, excerpt of the performance Composition en temps réel by Joāo Fiadeiro, Centre national de la Danse, 2004.
Michel Thomas, excerpt of a method for learning French, unknown date.
Scene of panic in Shanghai, 2015.
Feminist chant, 1970s.
Intervention during a protest in Marseille, vidéo posted on Facebook, 2019.
Excerpt of an interview between Belinda Annaloro and some children, 2014.
Teaser for a personal development seminar in Slovenia, YouTube, 2016
Phone call, personal recording, 2018
Breathing exercise in a singing class, personal recording, 2012.
Mister mv at Z event 2021, Twitch TV, 2021.
Paula White, excerpt from a preaching in support of the recount during the U.S. presidential election, 2020.
André Tubeuf, excerpt from the radio show André Tubeuf Mémoire, France Musique, 2021.
Street scene, personal recording, 2021.
Soccer coach at halftime, personal recording, year unkown.
Lynn Margulis, extrait d’un entretien, NHK-TV, années 80.
Extract from a videoconference, 2020.
Drawing of the Sorteo de Navidad, Christmas lottery, 2014.
Parrot training session, video posted on YouTube, 2007.